Is Self-Help Effective?

The question of whether self help works is a controversial one. While many self-help books are based on well-researched psychological treatments, they rarely have enough scientific evidence to support their claims.

The strongest self-help books are those written from a cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) perspective. Those are likely to have a good research base.

What is self help?

A self help group is an informal social network formed through the mutual sharing of experiences and feelings by members of a community. It focuses on forming relationships that encourage a variety of emotional responses such as trust, empathy and compassion. It also encourages members to form a new evaluation of their problems and their families.

The self help approach is based on the belief that people are capable of changing their lives if they work together. It is also based on the idea that change takes place through experiential learning and social interaction. It is an alternative to professional intervention or therapy and it has been used by a number of different organisations, including Alcoholics Anonymous (AA).

In a self help group, power relations are determined by the ability of members to relate to one another. It is important for the group to be able to recognise similarities among its members in order to maintain consistency and stability. In addition, the group should also be able to identify its goals. This will allow the group to structure itself properly.

How is self help effective?

There is no exact definition of self help since it involves a wide range of treatment modalities. The basic tenet of self-help is that people become experts on their own problems and that they take responsibility for their actions, decisions and behaviour. This is a powerful message that challenges the traditional stance of dependence on professionals and services.

Forming caring relationships in the group through mutual sharing of experiences encourages a variety of feelings including empathy, trust and compassion that sharpen the parent’s new evaluation of their situation. It is important for the group to have a clear structure and rules that facilitate the process of learning from each other’s experiences.

The self-help approach has the potential to improve family functioning and reduce drug dependency in children by integrating it into existing health and welfare facilities. In addition, it is a cost effective alternative to specialized treatments that may not be available for many families.

What are the drawbacks of self help?

Depending on the nature of the problem, some self help methods may cause more harm than good. It’s important to know the limitations of these approaches so that they are not over-used or misused.

There are also concerns about the quality and credibility of online self-help groups. It is possible that people will encounter falsehood or harmful advice because of restricted oversight or a lack of experience. It is recommended that people seek expert guidance when necessary to address specific prerequisites.

Another drawback of self-help is that it can lead to a sense of over-dependence on books and other resources, which could cause the person to become isolated from others. It is important to strike a balance between using self-help books and reaching out to supportive friends and family members. Additionally, some self-help books contain advice that is not necessarily based on well-researched psychological treatments. For example, John Gray’s popular Men Are From Mars, Women Are From Venus has been criticized for reinforcing stereotypes about men and women.

Shopping cart

0
image/svg+xml

No products in the cart.

Continue Shopping